Why Have Seismologists Moved from Richter to Moment Magnitude for Measuring Earthquake Intensity?

The Richter scale, developed in 1935 by Charles F. Richter, was the first scale to measure the size of earthquakes. The scale is logarithmic, meaning that each whole number increase on the scale represents a tenfold increase in measured amplitude and approximately 31.6 times more energy release. The scale was specifically calibrated for Southern California and used a particular type of seismograph, so it was most accurate for medium-sized earthquakes (M3 to M7) within a certain distance from the seismograph.

However, as our understanding of earthquakes has grown and technology has improved, seismologists have identified limitations with the Richter scale:

1. Regional Limitations: The Richter scale was based on California’s geology and the specific seismographs used at the time. It does not scale well for extremely large or small earthquakes, nor does it account for variations in the Earth’s crust in different regions of the world.
2. Energy Release: The Richter scale does not accurately estimate the energy released by very large earthquakes. The scale saturates around M7, meaning that it does not distinguish well between the energy released by the largest earthquakes, which can differ significantly.
3. Seismograph Limitations: The original scale was based on the recordings from a particular type of seismograph that is not used as widely today. Modern seismographs provide more detailed data, and the Richter scale does not take full advantage of this.

To address these limitations, the Moment Magnitude Scale (Mw) was introduced by Hank and Kanamori (1979). It is based on the seismic moment of an earthquake, which is a measure of the total energy released by the earthquake. The moment magnitude scale is now the most common scale for measuring the size of earthquakes for several reasons:

1. Global Applicability: Moment magnitude is calculated based on the physical properties of the earthquake (such as the rigidity of the Earth’s crust, the area of the fault that slipped, and the amount of slip) and can be used globally without regional corrections.
2. Accuracy for Large Earthquakes: The moment magnitude scale does not saturate like the Richter scale. It provides an accurate measure of the energy release for very large earthquakes (greater than M7), which is essential for understanding their potential impact.
3. Consistency: The scale provides a more uniform and consistent measure of an earthquake’s size, which is useful for both historical comparisons and scientific research.
4. Detailed Data Use: Modern seismographs record a full seismic wavefield. Moment magnitude takes advantage of this data to provide a more complete picture of an earthquake’s characteristics.

Because of these advantages, the moment magnitude scale has largely replaced the Richter scale for most seismological applications, especially for earthquakes that are recorded at long distances from the epicenter or that are very large.

Please reach us for comments and suggestions at info@quakelogic.net