QuakeLogic Blog Archive

Aging Dams, Climate Change and Earthquakes: How Monitoring Helps

Aging dam and spillway exposed to flooding, scouring and earthquake loads

In short: Aging dam monitoring helps prevent disasters by continuously collecting data from accelerometers, tiltmeters, piezometers, strain gauges, seepage monitors and weather stations, then automatically evaluating it against thresholds and alerting operators with action plans before deterioration becomes failure. QuakeLogic's SMARTDAM platform does this in the cloud with AI-assisted assessment, and its earthquake early warning can trigger actions such as opening spillways before shaking arrives.

Devastating climate change, including killer heat waves and severe flooding, adversely affects the infrastructures our communities rely on. Dams in particular become increasingly more vulnerable to climate change due to aging. Rapidly rising water levels and frequent floods add extra stress to dams, reservoirs and waterways, pushing them to their design limits. A failure to upgrade dams in response to deterioration in structural health may result in a catastrophic impact on the people and environment.

The most recent examples are the failed Edenville and Sanford Dams in Midland, Michigan due to rapidly rising waters after days of heavy rain. The collapsed Edenville Dam, constructed in 1924, was rated in unsatisfactory condition in 2018, while the Sanford Dam, which was built in 1925, was given a fair condition rating by the State.

In 2017, major flooding from the damaged Oroville Dam in Northern California forced the evacuation of nearly 200,000 Californians. The Oroville Dam was completed in 1968, toward the end of the golden era of dam construction. This was a wakeup call for owners of aging dams across the country, as climate change continues to add stress to these structures.

California has additional challenges due to active earthquake faults, including the Hayward and San Andreas faults, which scientists predict are due for a large earthquake. Among the dams now considered to be at risk are the Anderson Dam and the Calaveras Dam, both close to fault lines in Silicon Valley. According to the NY Times, California’s most troubled large dam is at Lake Isabella. This dam was built on the Kern River near Bakersfield by the Army Corps of Engineers in the 1950’s on what was thought to be an inactive fault. However, this fault has been active since then.

collapsed dam for "AGING DAMS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND EARTHQUAKES – HOW CAN MONITORING HELP TO PREVENT DISASTERS?"

Another major threat to dams is scouring. Numerous aging dams have experienced severe erosion of their unlined spillways. This erosion can lead to damage and even failure of dams and consequently can threaten public safety, properties, infrastructure and the wider local environment.

dam scour for "AGING DAMS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND EARTHQUAKES – HOW CAN MONITORING HELP TO PREVENT DISASTERS?"

There are a number of unfortunate examples of dams failing due to earthquakes, flooding or scouring where early signs of deficiencies might have been detected if a proper structural health monitoring (SHM) system had been in place.

Introducing SMARTDAM

QuakeLogic is the only company using a cloud-based, AI-powered technology platform to perform continuous, autonomous assessments using data from sensors on the dam structure.

QuakeLogic’s Sensor data Management, Assessment and Repository Technology (SMART) platform transforms a dangerous, aging dam into a SMART dam able to alert officials to critical deterioration. It also significantly reduces needed search and inspection efforts following any seismic or other impact event such as settlement, scouring, etc.

quakelogic ipad dam for "AGING DAMS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND EARTHQUAKES – HOW CAN MONITORING HELP TO PREVENT DISASTERS?"

The SMART platform integrates manually and digitally read sensor recordings into a fully automated unified monitoring system. It facilitates the acquisition and analysis of critical sensor data needed by the dam operators for proper operation and maintenance, and most importantly, for the safety assessment of the dam. It routinely collects, organizes and evaluates sensor data, and sends immediate notifications with ACTION PLANS upon exceedance of programmed thresholds, generating PDF reports regularly and on-demand.

The SMART platform is a cutting-edge system that works with various types of sensors such as accelerometers, tiltmeters, potentiometers, strain gauges, thermocouples, weather stations, piezometers and seepage monitors. Comprehensive analytic information is visible in real-time on the mobile-friendly dashboard, providing proof and PEACE OF MIND that a dam is performing as expected.

In addition to our SMART platform, our proprietary earthquake early warning (EEW) alerts provide a window of opportunity for action before earthquake shaking begins at the site. It can even trigger automated actions such as opening spillways, closing roads, etc. – when every second counts.

QuakeLogic’s monitoring system instantly detects any issue that could impact the structural integrity of the dam, allowing corrective measures to be implemented and avoiding a potential future disaster.

For details, contact us at sales@quakelogic.net

Key Takeaways

  • Edenville Dam (built 1924, rated unsatisfactory in 2018) and Sanford Dam (1925) failed in Midland, Michigan after days of heavy rain.
  • The 2017 Oroville Dam crisis forced nearly 200,000 Californians to evacuate; the dam was completed in 1968.
  • California dams near active faults include Anderson and Calaveras in Silicon Valley and Lake Isabella, built on a fault once thought inactive.
  • SMART integrates accelerometers, tiltmeters, potentiometers, strain gauges, thermocouples, weather stations, piezometers and seepage monitors into one dashboard.
  • Threshold exceedance triggers immediate notifications with action plans and PDF reports; EEW alerts can automate spillway opening or road closures.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are aging dams more vulnerable to climate change?

Aging dams are more vulnerable because climate-driven heat waves, intense rainfall and frequent floods push reservoirs and spillways to their design limits at the same time that decades of deterioration have weakened the structures. Rapidly rising water overloaded the 1924 Edenville Dam and 1925 Sanford Dam in Michigan, and the 2017 Oroville crisis in California showed that even large dams from the 1960s are at risk.

What sensors are used for dam structural health monitoring?

Dam structural health monitoring combines accelerometers for vibration and earthquake response, tiltmeters and potentiometers for movement and settlement, strain gauges for stress in concrete and steel, thermocouples for temperature, piezometers for pore-water pressure, seepage monitors for leakage, and weather stations for rainfall and reservoir context. QuakeLogic's SMART platform ingests both digitally and manually read sensors into one automated system.

How does SMARTDAM alert operators to dam problems?

SMARTDAM continuously collects, organizes and evaluates sensor data in the cloud using AI-assisted assessment. When any reading exceeds a programmed threshold, the platform sends an immediate notification together with a predefined action plan, and it generates PDF reports on a schedule or on demand. A mobile-friendly dashboard shows real-time analytics, giving operators engineering-quality evidence that the dam is, or is not, performing as expected.

Can earthquake early warning protect a dam?

Yes. QuakeLogic's earthquake early warning alerts arrive before strong shaking reaches the dam site, creating a window for protective action. The alert can trigger automated responses such as opening spillway gates or closing roads downstream, and it tells operators immediately that shaking is imminent. Combined with post-event sensor assessment, this reduces the search and inspection effort after an earthquake.

Which California dams are considered at risk from earthquakes?

Dams cited as at risk near California's Hayward and San Andreas faults include Anderson Dam and Calaveras Dam, both close to fault lines in Silicon Valley. Lake Isabella Dam on the Kern River near Bakersfield, built by the Army Corps of Engineers in the 1950s on a fault then believed inactive, has been described as the state's most troubled large dam because that fault has since proven active.

Need help with a project? QuakeLogic designs and supplies seismic monitoring, earthquake early warning, structural health monitoring, infrasound, and shake table systems. Browse QuakeLogic products or contact our engineering team with your site, structure, or test requirements.

Midland Michigan Dam Failures: Lessons for Dam Monitoring

Collapsed Edenville Dam in Midland, Michigan after the May 2020 failure and flooding

In short: The Edenville Dam (built 1924, rated unsatisfactory) collapsed and the Sanford Dam (built 1925, rated fair) was breached in Midland, Michigan on May 19, 2020 after days of heavy rain, forcing evacuations. With at least 1,680 US dams rated poor or unsatisfactory and the average dam over 50 years old, QuakeLogic's SMART platform offers continuous, AI-driven sensor monitoring with threshold alerts and automated reports.

When disaster strikes, we are all at risk! But the unprepared ones get hit the hardest.

The Edenville Dam collapsed and the Sanford Dam was breached in Midland, Michigan on last Tuesday (May 19) after days of heavy rain. In the midst of the Coronavirus pandemic, residents were ordered to evacuate because of rising waters. The collapsed Edenville Dam, built-in 1924, was rated in unsatisfactory condition while the Sanford Dam, which was built in 1925, was given a fair condition rating by the state.

Are other dams safe in the US?

On average, the nation’s dams are over 50 years old. At least 1,680 dams across the U.S. are currently rated in poor or unsatisfactory condition. These all pose potential risk according to this Associated Press article. Without urgent action, aging dams may not be able to adequately handle the intense rainfall and floods of a changing climate, as happened in the case of the Michigan dams. They may fail to protect people and property in cities and towns located nearby and downstream.

Introducing SMART DAMS

QUAKELOGIC is the only company using a cloud-based, AI-powered technology platform to perform continuous, autonomous structural assessments using data from sensors on the dam structure.

Deploying the QuakeLogic’s SENSOR DATA MANAGEMENT, ASSESSMENT, AND REPOSITORY TECHNOLOGY (SMART) on dams would significantly reduce needed search and inspection efforts in future events.

The SMART integrates manually and digitally read sensor recordings into a fully-automated unified monitoring system. It facilitates the acquisition and analysis of critical sensor data needed by the dam operators for proper operations and maintenance, and most importantly for the safety assessment of the dam.

The SMART helps to collect, organize, and evaluates sensor data routinely, sends immediate notifications upon exceedance of thresholds, and generate PDF reports regularly and on-demand.

collapsed dam 4 for "DAM FAILURES IN MIDLAND, MICHIGAN – WHEN A DISASTER HITS, WILL YOU BE PREPARED?"

The SMART is a cutting-edge system works with various types of sensors such as accelerometers, tiltmeters, potentiometers, strain gauges, thermocouples, weather stations, piezometers and seepage monitors. Comprehensive analytic information is visible in real-time on the mobile-friendly dashboard, providing proof and peace of mind that a dam is performing as expected.

In addition to SMART, our proprietary earthquake early warning (EEW) alerts provide a window of opportunity for action before earthquake shaking begins at the site. It can also trigger automated actions such as opening spillways, closing roads, etc. when every second counts.

Easy-to-understand, engineering-quality information about the real-time health of the dam supports operators to make informed decisions. Whether planning maintenance activities, or prioritizing critical response actions, QUAKELOGIC has you covered.

collapsed dam 5 for "DAM FAILURES IN MIDLAND, MICHIGAN – WHEN A DISASTER HITS, WILL YOU BE PREPARED?"

“Dams are vital in all communities. As we move toward recovery from COVID-19, it’s important to support the resiliency of dams by realtime monitoring and ensure that the dam owners have the support, tools, and resources to outsmart disasters.”

Key Takeaways

  • Edenville Dam (1924, rated unsatisfactory) collapsed and Sanford Dam (1925, rated fair) was breached after days of heavy rain.
  • At least 1,680 US dams are rated poor or unsatisfactory; the average American dam is over 50 years old.
  • SMART (Sensor Data Management, Assessment and Repository Technology) runs cloud-based, AI-powered continuous structural assessment.
  • SMART ingests accelerometers, tiltmeters, potentiometers, strain gauges, thermocouples, weather stations, piezometers and seepage monitors.
  • Threshold exceedance triggers immediate notifications; EEW alerts can automatically open spillways or close roads.

Frequently Asked Questions

What caused the dam failures in Midland, Michigan?

The Edenville Dam collapsed and the Sanford Dam downstream was breached on May 19, 2020 after days of heavy rain raised reservoir levels beyond what the aging structures could handle. Edenville, built in 1924, had been rated in unsatisfactory condition by the state and Sanford, built in 1925, was rated fair. Residents were ordered to evacuate as waters rose during the coronavirus pandemic.

How many dams in the United States are in poor condition?

According to an Associated Press analysis cited in the article, at least 1,680 dams across the United States are rated in poor or unsatisfactory condition, and the nation's dams average more than 50 years old. Without urgent action these aging dams may not handle the intense rainfall and floods of a changing climate, putting downstream communities at risk.

What is QuakeLogic SMART for dams?

SMART, short for Sensor Data Management, Assessment and Repository Technology, is QuakeLogic's cloud-based, AI-powered platform that performs continuous, autonomous structural assessments from sensors on a dam. It integrates manually and digitally read sensors into one unified system, evaluates data routinely, sends immediate notifications when thresholds are exceeded, generates PDF reports on schedule or on demand, and shows analytics on a mobile-friendly dashboard.

Which sensors can a dam monitoring system use?

QuakeLogic SMART works with accelerometers for vibration and earthquake response, tiltmeters for rotation, potentiometers for displacement, strain gauges, thermocouples, weather stations, piezometers for pore pressure and seepage monitors. Combining these data streams lets operators verify that the dam is performing as expected, plan maintenance and prioritize response actions after storms or earthquakes.

Can earthquake early warning protect a dam?

Yes. QuakeLogic's earthquake early warning alerts provide a window of seconds to tens of seconds before strong shaking reaches the dam site. In that window the system can trigger automated actions such as opening spillways or closing downstream roads, and notify operators, so protective measures begin before the shaking rather than after damage is observed.

Need help with a project? QuakeLogic designs and supplies seismic monitoring, earthquake early warning, structural health monitoring, infrasound, and shake table systems. Browse QuakeLogic products or contact our engineering team with your site, structure, or test requirements.

Monitoring Tunnels for Seismic Safety and Risk Management

Highway tunnel interior with structural health monitoring sensors for seismic safety assessment

In short: Tunnels are not automatically safe in earthquakes: liquefaction, slope failure, fault crossings and near-fault pulses damaged or collapsed tunnels in the 1906 San Francisco, 1952 Kern County and 1999 Duzce earthquakes, and the 2012 Sasago ceiling collapse showed components fail even without shaking. Tunnel seismic monitoring with real-time structural health monitoring measures accelerations, displacements and strains in the lining so officials can close a tunnel before it becomes deadly.

Monitoring tunnels for vibrations and deformations is not only critical during the construction phase but also their service life.

In 2012, the Tokyo-bound Sasago Tunnel suffered significant damage when nearly 150 concrete ceiling panels collapsed and crushed three vehicles, including a van carrying six people that caught fire. The deficiencies in mounting components of the ceiling panels were to blame.

But, are tunnels safe during an earthquake?

A common belief that underground structures are safer because they move with the soil, while structures above ground sway back and forth during the earthquakes appears to be misleading. The impact of earthquakes on tunnels can be severe due to ground failures such as liquefaction, strong ground shaking, and fault crossing.

Liquefaction takes place when saturated soft soil deposits loose load-carrying capacity during strong shaking. This phenomenon can cause the ground surrounding tunnels to deform and shift, with potentially severe impacts. The slope instability and fault crossings may also create permanent deformations leading to a collapse of the tunnel.

After the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, the Wrights railway tunnel in southern Santa Cruz mountains was closed for more than a year due to the collapse of approximately 100-m-long part crossing the San Andreas Fault Zone. Another railway tunnel crossing the White Wolf Fault was seriously damaged during the 1952 magnitude 7.5 Kern County earthquake associated with this fault (Kontogianni and Stiros, 2003).

In 1999 a magnitude 7.2 hit the Duzce region in Turkey. Close to the fault rupture, twin highway tunnels on the major highway connecting Ankara to Istanbul were under construction. The tunnels were partially collapsed due to intense pulses of earthquake motion (near-fault effects) as their lines cross the shear zone of the North Anatolian Fault.

tunnel 4 for "ON THE IMPORTANCE OF MONITORING TUNNELS FOR PROPER SEISMIC SAFETY ASSESSMENT AND RISK MANAGEMENT"

The excavation process during tunnel construction may itself trigger microearthquakes. The vibrations, therefore need to be monitored to identify such seismic activity whether they create any movements or cracks on the tunnel surface. The monitoring vibrations is also needed to estimate the rock formations ahead of the tunnel face to optimize the excavation parameters. Besides, the infrastructure surrounding the tunnel including buildings must be monitored especially in case of construction of new subway (metro) lines.

Structural health monitoring (SHM) system is essential for the seismic resilience of tunnels. A robust real-time SHM system not only allows for assessment of accelerations and deformations (displacements and strains) in tunnel linings but also facilitates the implementation of adaptive risk management. Such a system can assist the officials to make informed and timely decisions to protect people (such as drivers or construction workers) from life-threatening conditions. For example, the highway tunnel can be closed to traffic before any severe consequences take place. Such pro-active actions would not only save lives but also avoid liabilities.

tunnel 5 for "ON THE IMPORTANCE OF MONITORING TUNNELS FOR PROPER SEISMIC SAFETY ASSESSMENT AND RISK MANAGEMENT"

QuakeLogic is the only company providing cloud-based AI-powered disaster risk management solutions to prevent and reduce human and economic losses risen during and after earthquakes. Our cutting-edge technology platform performs real-time autonomous structural assessments using sensor data and sends rapid notifications after an event with the level of shaking intensity and whether structural integrity is compromised. For tunnels, our platform provides meaningful and easy-to-understand information immediately after an earthquake. This timely and critical information helps the officials to plan their emergency response. We also provide a web-based display where the sensor information can be monitored in real-time. This solution can provide great benefits especially for tunnels under construction phase.

For emergency measures and safety of tunnels, QuakeLogic provides advanced monitoring systems together with real-time and autonomous data analytics.

Key Takeaways

  • In 2012 about 150 concrete ceiling panels fell in Japan's Sasago Tunnel, crushing three vehicles, due to deficient mounting components.
  • The Wrights railway tunnel lost roughly 100 m where it crossed the San Andreas Fault in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake.
  • Twin highway tunnels near Duzce partially collapsed in the 1999 M7.2 earthquake from near-fault pulses on the North Anatolian Fault.
  • Tunnel excavation itself can trigger microearthquakes, so vibrations should be monitored during construction.
  • Real-time SHM of accelerations, displacements and strains enables closing a tunnel to traffic before severe consequences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are tunnels safe during an earthquake?

Not necessarily. The belief that underground structures are safer because they move with the surrounding soil is misleading. Tunnels can suffer severe damage from liquefaction of saturated soft soils, slope instability, strong shaking and especially fault crossings, where permanent ground deformation can collapse the lining. Historic failures include the Wrights tunnel in 1906, a White Wolf Fault railway tunnel in 1952 and the Duzce highway tunnels in 1999.

Why should tunnels be monitored during construction?

Excavation can itself trigger microearthquakes, and vibration monitoring reveals whether that seismic activity is causing movement or cracking in the tunnel surface. Vibration data also helps estimate rock conditions ahead of the tunnel face to optimize excavation parameters. In addition, surrounding infrastructure such as buildings above a new subway line must be monitored for settlement and vibration effects.

What does a structural health monitoring system measure in a tunnel?

A tunnel structural health monitoring system measures accelerations and deformations, meaning displacements and strains, in the tunnel lining in real time. QuakeLogic's cloud platform processes this sensor data autonomously, reports the shaking intensity after an earthquake, indicates whether structural integrity is compromised, and offers a web display so officials can watch conditions continuously, including during construction.

What happened in the Sasago Tunnel collapse?

In 2012 nearly 150 concrete ceiling panels in Japan's Tokyo-bound Sasago Tunnel collapsed, crushing three vehicles, including a van carrying six people that caught fire. Investigators blamed deficiencies in the components mounting the ceiling panels. The event shows that monitoring tunnels for deformation matters throughout their service life, not only during construction or earthquakes.

How does tunnel seismic monitoring help emergency response?

Real-time tunnel seismic monitoring gives officials immediate, easy-to-understand information after an earthquake about shaking intensity and whether the structure is compromised. With that data they can close a highway tunnel to traffic before severe consequences occur, protect drivers and construction workers, plan emergency response, and avoid liabilities. This adaptive risk management turns the monitoring system into a decision tool rather than a passive record.

Need help with a project? QuakeLogic designs and supplies seismic monitoring, earthquake early warning, structural health monitoring, infrasound, and shake table systems. Browse QuakeLogic products or contact our engineering team with your site, structure, or test requirements.